BUYER FOUNDATIONS / PRICE · EVIDENCE · CONTRACT

A stronger offer starts
with better evidence.

Separate a market comparison, an independent value opinion and your own cash limit before deciding what to offer.

Reviewed 26 October 2026 · Educational purchase guide. No current listing valuation, lending decision or contract drafting service.

Painted brick buildings with separate front steps and arched windows along King Street in Alexandria.
King Street, Old Town Alexandria, photographed in 2021. The street form is visible; unit count, tenure, use and ownership are not established by this photograph. Historical signs do not establish current availability. Photo: Beyond My Ken / CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source. Existing licensed DLG reference reused without pixel edits; not a DLG property.

Three numbers can answer different questions.

Asking price

The seller’s proposed price is a starting point for discussion. It is not evidence that a lender will support that amount or that another buyer has paid it.

CMA

A comparative market analysis assembles relevant sales and market competition to inform a pricing discussion. NAR’s guide describes sold, pending and active properties in that research. Ask for the evidence date, selection logic and limitations. [VAL353-2]

Appraisal

An independent opinion of value addresses a defined property and valuation assignment. CFPB explains that a lender may obtain an appraisal or another valuation method. Ask which method applies and request the report. [VAL353-1]

Value, condition and permission need different evidence.

A home inspection investigates physical condition; an appraisal answers a valuation question. One does not replace the other. Repairs can also affect a loan programme’s property requirements. [VAL353-9] A valuation is not confirmation that a conversion, deck, basement bedroom or extra dwelling is permitted; check the relevant records and specialist review through the linked buyer-preparation guide.

Comparable is a conclusion to justify.

Fannie Mae’s guide calls for physical and legal characteristics and the relevant market area to be considered. Site, finished area, rooms, style, condition and external factors can matter. Proximity alone does not establish comparability. Its guide concerns its own appraisal assignments; this reading is a question framework for your professional, not an instruction to perform an appraisal. [VAL353-3]

Swipe the table horizontally on smaller screens.

A comparable-evidence review
EvidenceQuestionDo not infer
Status and dateIs this a closed sale, pending contract or active ask? When did the transaction occur and when was the record checked?An asking price is not a closed price; a pending price may be unavailable.
Ownership and useIs the interest conveyed and legal use comparable? What do unit and association documents show?A similar facade does not establish the same ownership rights.
Area and layoutWere areas measured and classified consistently? Which spaces are above grade, below grade or unfinished?All advertised square footage is not automatically equivalent.
Condition and systemsWhat evidence supports roof age, renovation quality, HVAC and deferred-work differences?A new-looking kitchen does not resolve hidden condition issues.
Location and exposureDo the properties compete for similar buyers? Are site, traffic, flood exposure and access differences explained?A county average is not a valuation of a particular address.
Terms and concessionsWere price concessions, financing incentives or non-realty items involved? What market effect was supported?A seller credit is not always a dollar-for-dollar appraisal adjustment.

Fannie Mae requires adjustments to reflect market reaction, rather than a fixed rule of thumb. Concessions need analysis of their price effect. A contractor’s renovation invoice is not automatically the same as added market value. Ask the preparer to identify the support for adjustments and the uncertainty around the result. [VAL353-4]

A green-sided bungalow with a deep front porch, brick piers and exposed roof brackets.
Little Rock, Arkansas · 2008. Bruce W. Stracener · Photo source · Public domain (author release). DLG made no pixel edits; existing source edits remain. Historical reference, not a DLG property or listing.

These photographs illustrate building characteristics only. They are not a comparable-sale set, current listings or evidence of value.

A lower value can change the financing arithmetic.

The illustration below assumes a chosen loan-to-value ratio stays fixed and is applied to the lower of purchase price or appraised value. Fannie Mae describes that lower-of basis in its purchase-money LTV mortgage-insurance guidance. [VAL353-5] Your lender may structure financing differently; FHA, VA, USDA, second loans, assistance and appraisal alternatives are not modelled.

Invented example / 80% assumed LTV

$500,000 price · $480,000 appraisal

At 80% of price, the baseline loan would be $400,000 and purchase funds $100,000. At 80% of $480,000, the illustrated loan becomes $384,000 and purchase funds $116,000. The price-value gap is $20,000, while the added purchase funds are $16,000 under this constant-LTV assumption. Fees and reserves are separate.

The static example remains available without JavaScript. The tool processes entries in this page only; it does not save or send them. It does not calculate mortgage payments, underwriting limits, insurance, assistance, tax adjustments or a binding Closing Disclosure. Recheck financing and ongoing affordability separately.

Build a decision file before drafting terms.

Evidence and cash ceiling

Keep the property identity, comparable evidence and condition questions together. Set an affordable price and cash ceiling independently of the maximum preapproval. Include unpaid closing costs, reserves and any unconfirmed broker-payment obligation in the separate budget.

Terms and responsibility

Discuss the price, deposit, financing, inspection and appraisal provisions, included items, closing date and possession. Ask the agent and legal professional who must give each notice, by which method and by what exact date and time.

CFPB encourages planning financing and satisfactory-inspection conditions. For new construction, it also advises asking when a builder deposit is returnable. [VAL353-8] The effect of a condition depends on the actual contract, applicable law, notices and deadlines. Do not assume every low appraisal produces an automatic exit or every deposit is refundable.

Local handoff: Massachusetts, Virginia and Georgia

Use a local professional to review the current form and required disclosures. The following are preparation questions, not a state-by-state legal timetable:

Review representation and service agreements → · Choose the regional guide →

If the report is low, review evidence and contract options.

  1. Read the full report: check identity, area, condition, effective date and the explanation of comparable selection.
  2. Raise specific errors: ask the lender for its reconsideration-of-value (ROV) process. CFPB describes submitting factual corrections, missing evidence, unsuitable comparables or concerns about prohibited bias. A request does not promise a higher value. [VAL353-7]
  3. Reconcile the financing: ask the lender for the actual loan amount and conditions; update purchase cash and monthly costs.
  4. Review options before the deadline: discuss a price revision or other permitted resolution. CFPB notes negotiation and contract-dependent cancellation options, including potential costs. [VAL353-6] Do not allow a review request to consume a contractual notice deadline without advice.

Download comparable-evidence worksheet (CSV) ↗

Download offer decision checklist (CSV) ↗

Original blank question worksheets. Neither is a CMA report, appraisal, offer form or legal instrument. No personal financial records are requested by DLG.

Sources and scope.

The sources distinguish federal consumer education, Fannie Mae programme guidance and trade-association education. They do not establish the terms of an individual MA, VA or GA contract. Historical publication dates remain identified in the review notes.

VAL353-1 · checked 26 October 2026

CFPB — Understanding appraisals

Independent opinion of value; receiving appraisal and valuation copies.

Open source ↗

VAL353-2 · checked 26 October 2026

NAR — Pricing and CMA

CMA and the role of sold, pending and active comparables.

Open source ↗

VAL353-3 · checked 26 October 2026

Fannie Mae — Comparable sales

Physical/legal similarity and market area; Fannie Mae assignment context.

Open source ↗

VAL353-4 · checked 26 October 2026

Fannie Mae — Comparable adjustments

Market-supported adjustments and concession analysis.

Open source ↗

VAL353-5 · checked 26 October 2026

Fannie Mae — LTV basis in mortgage-insurance guidance

Lower-of-price-or-appraised-value basis in this purchase-money LTV context.

Open source ↗

VAL353-6 · checked 26 October 2026

CFPB — When the appraisal is below price

Get the report, discuss price and review contract options.

Open source ↗

VAL353-7 · checked 26 October 2026

CFPB — Reconsideration of value

Borrower evidence of factual error, unsuitable comparables or bias.

Open source ↗

VAL353-8 · checked 26 October 2026

CFPB — Finding the right home

Budget, representation, financing and inspection conditions; builder deposits.

Open source ↗

VAL353-9 · checked 26 October 2026

CFPB — Independent home inspection

Inspection differs from appraisal; repair and financing complications.

Open source ↗

VAL353-10 · checked 26 October 2026

Georgia Consumer Ed — Making an offer

Offer, contingencies and earnest-money orientation.

Open source ↗
TOP